Welcome to Mathias Sandwich Shop
At Mathias Sandwich Shop, nestled in the heart of Columbia, SC, a passion for wholesome, hearty food shines through. This cherished local gem delights patrons with a diverse menu of sandwiches, burgers, and hearty salads, all crafted from quality ingredients. Renowned for its friendly atmosphere, the shop offers a casual dining experience with options for takeout, delivery, and catering. Customers rave about the famous pimento cheese burger and delightful breakfast offerings, making each visit feel like a pleasant surprise. With a commitment to community and delicious home-cooked meals, Mathias Sandwich Shop stands as a beloved staple in the area.
- 7235 St Andrews Rd Columbia, SC 29212 United States Hotline: (803) 781-4002
Welcome to the delightful world of Mathias Sandwich Shop, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Columbia, SC. Situated at 7235 St Andrews Rd, this casual eatery is not just a sandwich shop; it's a community favorite known for its warm atmosphere and mouthwatering menu. With a focus on fresh, quality ingredients, Mathias Sandwich Shop delivers a dining experience that is both satisfying and heartwarming.
Mathias Sandwich Shop offers a diverse selection of sandwiches, burgers, and salads that cater to various tastes and dietary preferences. Whether you're a carnivore or a vegetarian, you'll find something to love here.
- Signature Dishes: Don't miss their renowned pimento cheese burger, which has clients raving about its unique flavor. The chicken salad and egg salad are also consumer favorites, offering a delightful option for a lighter meal.
- Buffet Offerings: The lunch and barbecue buffets provide an incredible opportunity to indulge in a variety of dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone at the table.
- Breakfast Classics: Mathias also shines in the breakfast department with crowd-pleasers such as French toast and omelets, making it a great spot for morning gatherings.
Not only does Mathias Sandwich Shop serve exceptional food, but it also boasts a range of amenities that enhance the dining experience. With options for takeout, delivery, and even reservations, it's easy to enjoy their dishes in a way that suits your lifestyle. Families will appreciate the kid-friendly menu and the good for groups atmosphere that fosters friendly gatherings. Plus, outdoor seating, free Wi-Fi, and on-site parking ease your visit, while patrons enjoy a moderate noise level that’s perfect for casual conversations.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment that Mathias Sandwich Shop offers both great food and service. Repeat visitors emphasize the friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure your experience is memorable. The atmosphere is reminiscent of a classic diner, invoking nostalgia while serving up contemporary flavors.
While the parking situation can be tight, patrons agree that it’s worth the effort to find a spot for such gratifying meals. If you're in Columbia, SC, visiting Mathias Sandwich Shop is more than just a meal; it's an experience filled with flavor and comfort. You might just find your new favorite sandwich in their rotating specials and timeless favorites.
So why wait? Head over to Mathias Sandwich Shop and indulge in a culinary delight that celebrates community, comfort, and, of course, hearty sandwiches.

Always always good! I usually don't toast the bread, but tried it this time. It was different. I personally prefer it untoasted. The chicken salad never misses or the egg salad!

The food was amazing and the service was great as always. If you've never been here before I highly suggest it. Also this place offers amazing catering options

Hands down one of the best pimento cheese burgers around. Onion rings are also fantastic. This little place is easy to drive by, but is honestly one of very few local, diner style restaurants left in town. Even their simple breakfast items like French toast and omelets are great. It's always such a pleasant surprise eating here, like you get to experience it for the first time with each visit. They offer a buffet as well on certain days, which vary with great breakfast/lunch options. While you don't really have a waitress, the staff is always at the counter to offer refills. The only real gripe about this fantastic business is the parking situation (which I'm sure they have heard a thousand times.) Best times to go are the off hours of the day, and week days. Definitely worth finding a spot!

Mathias is a hidden gem. It's a small sandwich shop that serves burgers, salads and even desserts. Parking can be tight but it's worth it. The mirror windows can be deceiving from the outside. I always thought this place was a bar. However, once inside I discovered a local diner. The employees were really nice and recommended the pimento cheese burger, which was amazing. They also advertise a buffet. Although, I didn't see the buffet I'm excited to go back when they have it. I would recommend Mathias and plan on going back again.

Good Food and Good Prices! You need to check this place out when you get a chance. Very friendly staff!

Great local establishment. Restaurant has been in the community for years and is a nice place to get cheap food food. There is a buffet at breakfast and lunch depending on the day. They also cater. I've come here for years to get both and never had anything I didn't enjoy. They also have some of the better sweet tea in the area.

I just enjoyed a very good pimento burger along with fresh cut french fries at Mathis Sandwich Shop in Irmo. This place is busy as the food is varied and good. They even have a meat and vegetables option. Their breakfasts are great along with the sandwiches they have for lunch and catering. The tea is home brewed which is an added plus.